Can I customize my submission form?

With over 1,000 journals using Scholastica for peer review management ranging in discipline from STEM to the Humanities, we understand that each journal may have different needs when it comes to collecting information that’s crucial to the peer review process during the submission stage. That's why our submission form is ready-built with easy customization options to gather and/or require additional data fields as needed.

This help doc walks through current submission form customization opportunities to help you provide more instructions for authors and get more information from them before peer review, ensuring your workflow is as efficient as possible.

Please note: These customizations are only available for journals subscribed to our Peer Review System. Journals that participate in the law review submission pool cannot request these changes.

Click on a customization option below to jump to the section.

I want to require specific information from authors (e.g., ORCiD, Institution, etc.)

Our submission form currently requires authors to include their name and the email address for the corresponding author while other fields like Institution and Department are optional.  

If your journal wants to require that authors fill out a specific field upon submission, our form is flexible enough to require any combination of the following fields :

  • ORCiD (learn more here)
  • Institution
  • Department
  • Degrees
  • Emails of non-corresponding authors
  • Link to a personal website

  • When choosing specific information to be required, the required fields will appear for both co-authors and the corresponding author. For example, if you would like to require the ORCiD field for the corresponding author, that field will also be required for all co-contributors of the manuscript.
  • At the moment,
    • Other customizations cannot be added to this section
    • The text for existing fields cannot be adjusted (e.g fields similar to ORCID, Institution, Link)

Where does this information appear post submission? 

All of the information will appear under the Author Details section of the Editor Work Area. This allows your editors to easily refer to the information when necessary.

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

Reminder : Please be thoughtful when choosing specific information to be required as the required fields will appear for all co-authors as well as the corresponding author. For example, if you want to require the ORCiD field for the corresponding author, that field will also be required for all co-contributors on the submission.

Require authors to choose from preset list of keywords

Our submission form currently requires authors to include at least one keyword to describe the topics covered in their manuscript. Ordinarily, your authors can enter as many keywords as they'd like and whichever keywords they like. If, however, you request that we use a preset list of keywords, your authors will be required to select only their chosen keywords from your list.

Where does this information appear post submission? 

Keywords — whether chosen from a preset list or not — will show on the manuscript work area under the abstract area.

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

Add CRediT fields for author contributions

CRediT, which became an ANSI/NISO standard in 2022, consists of 14 research contributor roles that journals can include in the body and machine-readable metadata of their articles to increase recognition of and transparency around the various possible forms of research contribution beyond writing and editing.

If you'd like to offer authors the chance (or even require them) to denote exactly what work each author was responsible for, you can ask that we add CRediT role fields to the author step of your submission form.

Screenshot of the author step of a submission form that has enabled the CRediT role field(s)

Where does this information appear post submission? 

Any CRediT information entered by your submitting author(s) will show under the author name in the manuscript work area for that submission.

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

I want my authors to specify the type of article they are submitting

Some journals have different submission vetting and reporting processes based on the type of submission that an author is making. By adding the ‘Article Type’ field to your submission form, you can make managing and tracking submissions by type easier for your editorial team.

Definition : What is an Article Type? 

Broadly speaking, an article type is a general category that a manuscript may fall into. Some examples of article types include Book Review, Conference Proceedings, Research Brief, Original Research, etc. 

What Article Types should I choose?

As a best practice, we recommend journals use article types that correspond to the industry-standard options included in JATS, though article types can be unique to your journal’s needs.

As a general rule, you'll want to provide article type options that are obvious enough that your submitting authors can easily understand which type their submission belongs to. As long as that is apparent, your options can be whatever makes the most sense for your journal. 

Note : If you are using Scholastica’s OA Publishing Platform, then when you publish an article, you will still be required to choose an article type for each article that is stored/recorded for indexing purposes and must conform to JATS XML standards. The article type entered on the submission form does NOT impact the article type chosen during publishing (image of choosing the article type when publishing). 

Where does this new field appear on the submission form? 

The Article Type field will appear in the Metadata section of the form immediately following the title field. 

Where does the Article Type appear for editors?

The Article Type will appear in two places : 

1. In the Manuscript Table

There will be a new column titled ‘Article Type’ (you’ll also be able to search the Manuscript Table by Article Type).

2. In the Editor Work Area

The Article Type will appear in front of the title of the manuscript in the Editor Work Area.

Additionally, if your journal requests a data pull, the article type will be included in the data that we provide you.

Where does the article type appear for reviewers? 

The Article Type will appear in front of the title of the manuscript in the Reviewer Work Area 

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled out, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

I want my authors to affirm specific information about their submission

Peer review depends on trust, and a big part of that is authors complying with journal policies. One way to ensure that an author has complied with your policies is by adding an “affirmations” section to your submission form. Each author will be required to check all affirmations prior to confirming and submitting their manuscript.

Examples of affirmations

  • The paper complies with ethical policies
  • All authors listed on the paper contributed substantially
  • This manuscript is not under consideration elsewhere
  • The authors have included an attached conflict of interest disclosure form 

Where do the affirmations appear on the submission form?

Once added, there will be a new section called ‘Affirmations’. The corresponding/submitting author will be required to check all affirmations prior to confirming and submitting their manuscript.

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled out, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

Add a JEL codes section (economics journals)

Is your journal's discipline primarily economics? If so, you may want to request that we include a field for submitting authors to provide the appropriate JEL classification codes for their given article.

Where does the JEL code field appear on the submission form?

Once added, your authors will see a field on the Metadata step prompting them to click, then either browse the list that appears or begin typing to search for the proper code. Once they click the code they'd like to add it will be successfully attached to the article and they can add another until they're satisfied.

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled out, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

I want my authors to include information about the funding they received

If your journal wants to (or your authors need to) provide details about the funding that supported this article being written, you can include a Funding Sources section on your journal's submission form. The fields that authors will be able to enter are:

  • Funder name
  • Grant number
  • Grant recipient

The Funder name field pulls from Crossref's Funder Registry so authors can easily find their funder or issuer of their grant.

Where does the funding source information appear on the submission form?

Once added, there will be a new section called 'Funding Sources'. The corresponding/submitting author will not be required to add funding sources, but can choose to add them prior to confirming and submitting their manuscript.

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled out, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

I want to add specific file upload fields (e.g. Waivers, Cover Letters, Figures, Tables, etc.)

If your journal would like authors to submit specific documents / files in addition to the main manuscript file, you can add specific upload fields to the Files section of your submission form. Examples of specific files may include a cover letter, tables, a copyright waiver, or a conflict of interest disclosure form. Our submission form allows you to add these specific file upload fields to ensure that an author will know which files to submit, including all required documents during the submission process. 

Note: The main manuscript file is always required for file uploads and cannot be disabled.

Example of when an author does not upload required files

All files can be viewed by going to the manuscript details page and scrolling down to the “Files” table. All of the files included with the submission will appear in the table, labeled as requested.

How to add this option to your submission form

When you add custom file upload fields, you can control everything from the label of the file to the file extensions that are allowed. 

To add this option, please use this template to provide the details for the new file fields that you would like to add and email the completed spreadsheet to support@scholasticahq.com. Please note that if you require a specific file upload on your submission form, authors that are submitting to your journal will NOT be able to complete their submission without uploading the specific file.

The table below is an example of the information that we need from you in order to add this option to your submission form.

Label Hint Text Do you require this (Yes/No) Will you allow single files or multiple files (Single/Multiple) What file types are allowed
Cover Letter None Yes Single .docx, .pdf
Title Page None Yes Single .docx, .pdf
Figure(s) Figures must be a minimum of 1080px wide or long Yes Multiple .jpg, .svg, .png
Table(s) Tables must be labeled sequentially, e.g.: "Table 1", "Table2", etc. Yes Multiple .docx, .pdf, .xls, .csv
Scan of Medical License If comfortable, please upload a scanned image of your medical license No Single .jpg, .png, .pdf

I want to add a character or word limit to a text field

Have you noticed a pattern where your authors supply you with a veritable essay's length of text in a field where you were hoping for a quick summary? If so, you can request that a character or word limit be applied to a text field. These limitations are available for the following fields:


If you're unsure which limitation you'd prefer to apply — character vs. word — you can easily tally the number of characters and words in a given line of text using a character and word counter online. Example here.


Please note: If you're using Scholastica Peer Review and Scholastica OA Publishing and want to collect an article lede from the author at time of submission to use for their article when published, we require that the lede be no longer than 30 words, not 30 characters.


How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled out, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

I want to include special instructions for each Section

You may find that authors regularly email your journal to ask about certain submission guidelines or perhaps you’ve found that you’re frequently following up with researchers post-submission because they forgot to include required information when submitting. 

In order to try and prevent this extra work, you can include instructions for one or more entire steps (sections) on your submission form. The instructions that you add can help to better guide your authors through each step of the submission form, helping you get ahead of questions and hopefully reducing the likelihood of information being unintentionally omitted. 

Where do these instructions appear on the submission form? 

You can add instructions to any section of the submission form. Below are the current sections on the submission form: 

  • Metadata
  • Authors 
  • Files 
  • Reviewers (*Optional, based on your Configuration Options setup)
  • Affirmations (*Optional, see above)

Example of what it would look like to add instructions to the ‘Metadata’ Section

How to add this field to your submission form

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled out, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!


FAQs

What is a Section, Field, Label, etc.?

Anatomy of the submission form 

Below we point out some of the most common terminology we use when customizing your submission form.

Sections vs Fields

  • Sections are the "steps" in the submission form that the author has to complete before they can submit. This includes the "Metadata",  "Authors", "Files", etc. You can find these on the left hand side of the submission form.
  • Fields collect specific information within each section. Each section includes one or more fields (e.g. the Metadata section includes fields for Title, Keywords, etc).

Labels and hint text

  • The label is the name that is given to a specific field (e.g Title, Abstract, Primary Manuscript) 
  • The hint text is the small instructional text that is provided underneath the label displayed in gray

To learn what the standard submission form looks like, see Submitting a Manuscript

How do I enable the Reviewers to recommend / avoid section?

  • To allow authors to suggest reviewers during their submission, admin editors can go to the configuration options of their journal's settings and click on "Author Options." From there they can check the boxes to enable the feature that allows authors to recommend / avoid reviewers

How do I collect optional demographic information from authors?

If you're the admin editor of your journal on Scholastica, you can toggle on/off the optional demographic information when authors submit to your journal. For step by step instructions, see this help doc : Demographic information on Scholastica


Additional customization options:


If the customizations suggested so far don’t fit your needs, you may find a better fit from the broader and more flexible range of customization options listed below.

Single Line Text

If your journal would like authors to provide a short snippet of text, like an answer to a question or a brief sentence, you can have them do so by adding a new “Single Line Text” field to your submission form. The journal can set this field as required or optional for submitting authors.

Examples of how Single Line Text can be used

  • Deadline to return a decision
  • E-signature

Multi Line Text

Some journals ask their authors to provide them with text that might be multiple sentences or lines of text. Adding a “Multi Line Text” field will allow your authors to enter more text than fits in the single line text format.

Examples of how Multi Line Text can be used

  • Ledes
  • Author biographies
  • The author’s mailing address, if needed by the journal

Checkboxes

Does your journal want to display text with a corresponding checkbox? You can request a checkbox be added to your submission form with fully customizable text. This option can be useful if you would like to ask authors to opt-in to something or if you'd like authors to select multiple options in a single field. Please note that if you want to require authors to affirm something, like verification that their submission is original, you'll want to instead request an affirmation checkbox.

Examples of how Checkboxes can be used

  • "Please check this box if you would like the editorial team to contact you regarding our annual conference.
  • "Please check this box if you are submitting this paper on behalf of the first author".
  • "Please select all options that apply to you: Option 1 / Option 2 / Option 3"

Radio Buttons

Some journals need to ask authors to select between mutually exclusive choices. Adding radio buttons to your submission form is the best option when you’re collecting information and want the author to specifically select only one option out of multiple.

Examples of how Radio Buttons can be used

  • Has this paper been presented at a conference?
    • Yes
    • No
  • If the manuscript is accepted for publication, are you interested in making your article open access for an additional fee?
    • Yes
    • No
    • I'm not sure yet

This format will allow you to use dropdowns for any requests similar to the Article Types request. This option is the best when you want mutually exclusive options but would prefer to have them listed in a drop down format rather than a series of buttons.

Examples of how Dropdowns can be used

  • Which of our editors would you like to manage your paper?
    • Susan Scholar
    • Edward Editor
    • Rachel Researcher
  • For which edition of the journal would you like your submission to be considered?
    • Spring
    • Fall

    • Special Editions of Issues

Here’s how you can request these customizations:

Please download and fill out the submission form customization template. Once the appropriate information has been filled out, just attach the updated file in an email to support@scholasticahq.com and we can begin adding those customizations to your submission form!

Where will these customizations appear after an author has submitted?

All of the information that authors submit will be accessible from the manuscript work area. Any customizations besides the author information and the additional file uploads will be included at the bottom of the page under the header, “Additional Information”. Click the header to expand it and the editors of the journal can quickly view what information authors have submitted.

What customizations are not currently supported?

Due to technical limitations, there are some customizations that we cannot provide. Please note that:

  • Custom fields are currently limited to the 'Metadata' section

If you're still not sure whether or not your customization request is supported, please feel free to contact us to learn more!